News and analysis from The Center for Michigan • http://thecenterformichigan.net
©2014 Bridge Michigan. All Rights Reserved. • Join us online at http://bridgemi.com

Original article URL: http://bridgemi.com/2013/09/mlks-dream-not-yet-realized-at-college-graduation-its-not-even-close/

Talent & education

MLK’s dream not yet realized at college graduation – it’s not even close

Why is one of these college students more likely to graduate than the other? Michigan colleges are struggling to figure it out

Why is one of these college students more likely to graduate than the other? Michigan colleges are struggling to figure it out. (Bridge photo by Monique Belser)

Paulette Granberry Russell remembers walking on the sprawling campus of Michigan State University as a scared, under-prepared freshman.

“I was an African-American woman and first-generation (to attend college in her family),” she said.  “I didn’t have the tools or the networks that would have made this an easier transition.”

Despite challenges, she earned a diploma, and eventually a job at MSU, where this week she can walk across campus and see minority students facing the same struggles she faced.

“I see myself in these students,” said Granberry Russell, director of the Office of Inclusion and Intercultural Initiatives at MSU. “I know what a difference it made for me to have access to higher education.”

Yet the diploma gap between black and white students is widening at MSU, as well as many campuses across Michigan.

At Michigan State University, a black-white gap that was a disheartening 18 percentage points in 2002 grew to 26 percentage points by 2011; Central Michigan’s gap more than tripled in a decade.

At Wayne State University, located in the nation’s largest African-American-majority city, white students are five times more likely to earn a bachelor’s degree than their black classmates. In 2010, one in 10 black students who’d enrolled at Wayne State six years earlier had earned a degree. 

(See the black-white graduation gap for Michigan Universities)

A year later, the figure was one in 13 – one of the lowest African-American graduation rates in the nation.

Black college students aren’t the only ones hurt by the diploma gap. Granberry Russell calls it a “drain on the economy” for African-American students to not succeed in college. “We know there is untapped potential,” she said.

“Every major university is facing this challenge,” said Mark Jackson, director of the Upward Bound program at Eastern Michigan University, another school where the black-white graduation gap is higher than it was a decade ago. “It should be an indication of the magnitude of this problem.”

Moving more African-American students from freshman orientation to graduation ceremonies is a test Michigan can’t afford to fail. In a state that needs more college graduates to invigorate an increasingly high-tech economy, graduation rates — particularly for minorities — need to improve.

Yet the state, which makes overall graduation rates a performance funding measure for Michigan’s 15 public universities, doesn’t track the gap between white and minority degrees.

Brandy Johnson, executive director of Michigan College Access Network, thinks colleges need to pick up their game.

“Michigan has one of the highest college-enrollment rates among low-income students (in the U.S.),” Johnson said. “Bu they’re not completing college. It’s net positive. But we can’t use that as an excuse. We need to get them through (to a degree). We need to build the plane while we’re flying it.”

The racial graduation divide is stubbornly wide across the country. A gap that was 18 percentage points in 2006 (60 percent for whites compared to 42 percent for African-Americans) grew to 22 points in 2011 (62 percent to 40 percent).

Among the public universities with substantial minority enrollment, Wayne State had a 31 percentage point graduation gap; Oakland University, 26 points, and Central Michigan, 23 points. The University of Michigan made significant strides, narrowing the diploma gap in Ann Arbor from 22 percent in 2002 to 13 percent a decade later.

Among Michigan private colleges, Lawrence Tech had a troubling black-white graduation gap of 42 percent, with white students earning degrees at almost five times the rate of African-Americans. The rate is hard to statistically quantify on many private campuses because most of Michigan’s private universities don’t have substantial African-American enrollment.

Much of the challenge of closing the diploma gap starts long before students walk onto campus. On average, minority students tend to come from lower-income families and be less academically prepared for the rigors of universities. Nationally, a quarter of white high school graduates were considered fully academically prepared for college, according to the ACT’s annual report released in August; only five percent of black high school graduates were considered fully ready.

In 2005, the University of Michigan-Dearborn decided to try to attract valedictorians from high schools in surrounding counties. The result was a significantly higher African-American six-year graduation rate. The initiative was dropped the next year, and graduation rates slipped.

The point, made by Roma Heaney, director of institutional research at UM-Dearborn: graduation rates say more about who is coming in the door of the classroom, than they do about the classrooms themselves.

Johnson and her Michigan College Access Network understand the relationship between standardized test scores and college success. But keeping kids out of college who are at risk of dropping out is the wrong decision, even if lower graduation rates put universities in danger of losing state funds. A better response for the students, the schools, and the state, is to find ways to help those students stay in school, Johnson said.

UM-Dearborn offers scholarships to high-performing students in low-income communities to get kids on campus, then offers career counseling and African-American mentors from the faculty to keep them there.

Eastern Michigan University has a conditional enrollment program for academically iffy students, in which students are required to meet regularly with faculty and older students.

“Ultimately, you want to assist those black students to become good college students,” EMU’s Jackson said.

Some schools around the country have managed to erase the black-white graduation gap. A report by Education Trust points out that the University of North Carolina-Greensboro graduates African-American and white students at the same rate. That same report admonishes Michigan State University for having a black-white graduation gap of more than 15 percentage points every year for the past decade.

“There is a continuing trend of inequitable success outcomes at Michigan State University,” the report says.

While the gap is wide in East Lansing, Granberry Russell appropriately points out that MSU still graduates African-American students at a rate higher than the national average (55 percent earn a degree within six years, compared to 40 percent across the U.S.) “That’s not good enough,” said Granberry Russell. “We are continually assessing our efforts.”

MSU has a transition program for students entering college, and has moved some of its academic advisors to the residence halls. Some minority students “come out of high schools that have their own challenges,” Granberry Russell said. “But we believe they have the ability to succeed at Michigan State. When we admit a student to Michigan State, we have a responsibility to provide them with the support in able to persist, succeed and graduate.”

Looking at the statistics, Jackson knows there’s still a long way to go.

“If society is going to change,” he said, “it’s going to change with higher education.”

Senior Writer Ron French joined Bridge in 2011 after having won more than 40 national and state journalism awards since he joined the Detroit News in 1995. French has a long track record of uncovering emerging issues and changing the public policy debate through his work. In 2006, he foretold the coming crisis in the auto industry in a special report detailing how worker health-care costs threatened to bankrupt General Motors.

4 comments from Bridge readers.Add mine!

  1. Ren Farley

    How were these graduation rates calculated? If a student matriculated at
    Wayne in 2002, dropped out for a year or two and then graduated from
    MIT in 2008, is she counted as a college graduate or a non-graduate?
    Thanks

  2. Rita Casey

    Your article does not mention poverty, which is a condition that directly affects the time it takes students to finish college. I teach at Wayne State, which has many students who come from families hit hard by the hard economic conditions in Michigan, particularly in Metro Detroit. 25% of Wayne students are African American.

    This semester, as is my custom, I asked the 125 undergraduates in the courses I teach to tell me about their employment this semester. Over half of them are working full time. Just a half dozen are able to devote all of their time to their education, without being employed. The implications of those facts are these: It is nearly impossible to finish college in 4-6 years if you are working full time. It is quite challenging to finish in 6 years if you work half time.

    Yes, minority students should have a strong system of supports to help them through college. However, for students who are poor – whether minority or not – that support should include access to financial resources. Policy makers also need to have a realistic idea of the time it takes student to get through college while being employed several hours per week.

  3. Chuck Jordan

    Michigan is one of the most segregated states in the union when it comes to education. The segregation and poverty mean students who do manage to get into college rarely have the support and skills to succeed. And yet many do. Celebrate those who do succeed. Find out why.

  4. Charles Richards

    “(Brandy) Johnson and her Michigan College Access Network understand the relationship between standardized test scores and college success. But keeping kids out of college who are at risk of dropping out is the wrong decision, even if lower graduation rates put universities in danger of losing state funds.” I strongly disagree with the second sentence. Unfortunately, the sentence is not clear, not meaningful; whether it is to be supported or not depends on the criteria used to define “risk of dropping out”. Does she mean a ten percent chance of dropping out, or a ninety percent chance? Surely, she does not advocate allocating sufficient resources to ensure the graduation of a student who has a ninety percent chance of failing?

    Doing so would surely benefit that individual, but would it promote the general welfare? Investing the same resources would ensure the graduation of nine students who had a ten percent chance of failing. Society would have the benefit of nine educated graduates versus one. Obviously, that’s a much better investment of limited resources. And it has always been the case that using resources more efficiently is what has elevated human welfare.

    As is often the case (regrettably all too common) there is a conflict between the welfare of particular members of society, and society as a whole. Arthur Okun, Chairman of the Council of Econmic Advisers under John Kennedy, and then Lyndon Johnson, wrote a small, but classic book about this dilemma called Equality and Efficiency: The Big Tradeoff. In it, he laid out the necessity of choosing between equality, or fairness, and the promotion of the general welfare. He posed a choice for the reader: if you were transferring resources from the top income decile to the bottom income decile, but were doing so in a leaky bucket and what leaked from the bucket was permanently lost to society, what level of lost resources would you tolerate before you concluded that the losses to society as a whole outweighed the benefits to the bottom decile? He personally would have tolerated a loss of ninety percent of the transferred resources.

    That is certainly a legitimate choice, and he had the honesty and integrity to explicitly make that choice on the record. That is something all policy advocates should, but rarely, do. Ms. Johnson should do so. What is really regrettable is that it is unlikely that neither Ms. Johnson or Mr. French were aware they were making such a decision.

Leave your comment...

Your email address will not be published.

Invest in non-partisan journalism.

Donate to The Center for Michigan.Find out why.