- Gov. Gretchen Whitmer is hesitant to opt in to the Trump administration’s federal school tax credit starting next year
- Whitmer told Detroit-area leaders at a Friday event that it may make more sense for Gov.-elect Jocelyn Benson to decide
- Whitmer also said she won’t run for president and reflected on her relationship with Trump and her legacy as governor
BIRMINGHAM — Outgoing Gov. Gretchen Whitmer isn’t yet sold on signing Michigan up for the Trump administration’s federal school tax credit program, telling a group of Detroit-area business and community leaders Friday that the decision might be better left to her successor.
Whitmer said she hasn’t made a final call on opting into the Education Freedom Tax Credit, designed to offer taxpayers federal income tax credits of up to $1,700 in exchange for donating to scholarship granting organizations. Those groups would then distribute the money to eligible students for education expenses, including private school tuition.
States have to let the Trump administration know by Jan. 1 whether they’re opting in. That will be Gov.-elect Jocelyn Benson’s first day in office.
Related
- What to know about school tax credit program. Will Michigan opt in?
- Jocelyn Benson has big plans. Michigan has big problems
- Michigan Democrats promised lower costs. Here are 7 ideas
More than 30 states have already signed up, including some with Democratic governors, but Whitmer said Friday that even if she were to do so, “there’s no guarantee that the next administration will actually implement it and see it through.”
“So opting in, at this juncture, I don’t know makes a whole lot of sense for us,” she said at a Detroit Free Press Breakfast Club event, noting that the incoming Benson administration “will have time to do it on Jan. 1 if they want to.”
Speaking with reporters after the event, Whitmer said she sees upsides and downsides to the tax credit program.
“But I don’t know that it’s appropriate for me to obligate the next administration,” she said, noting that she’s discussed the matter with Benson. “Everyone’s grappling with the arguments on both sides to figure out what makes the most sense for Michigan.”
Benson, a fellow Democrat, criticized the tax credit program in September, saying that it would be “reckless and irresponsible” to “commit taxpayer dollars to a program under Trump’s control with zero transparency or assurance it will deliver for Michigan students.”
Some business and education leaders want Whitmer to opt in while she has the chance, arguing the program, created under the Trump administration’s “One Big Beautiful Bill,” helps raise money for students to succeed in schools of their choice, whether public or private.
But critics view the program as a backdoor, voucher-like way to divert public dollars to private schools, which is generally prohibited under the state Constitution. Forty-nine Democratic legislators this week signed a letter urging Whitmer not to opt in.
Whitmer could not seek reelection due to the state’s term-limits law and will leave office at noon on Jan. 1. Benson will be sworn in then and will begin her term with a Democratic majority in both chambers of the Legislature.
In Friday’s wide-ranging discussion with Detroit Free Press columnist and television journalist Carol Cain, Whitmer also reflected on her legacy as governor, offered advice for incoming elected officials, shared more details about her up-and-down relationship with President Donald Trump — and once again insisted that she won’t run for president in 2028.
Talks with Trump
During her first term, Whitmer and Trump frequently clashed on COVID-19 policy, and the president’s frequent attacks on her leadership drew national attention to her actions as governor.
Trump’s insults from that time were a “low point” in her tenure as governor, Whitmer said Friday, “not because it hurt my feelings or because I couldn’t take criticism.”
“It was a low point because I was worried that they would withhold support,” she continued. “We needed masks. We needed gloves … and that was my fear, that they would be petty and withhold things.”
That relationship evolved after Trump won reelection in 2024, when Whitmer developed a working relationship with the president even as she disagreed with him on issues like steep Canadian tariffs.
Whitmer said Friday that Trump “still calls me every once in a while,” recalling one notable post-primary discussion where he asked her whether Republican US Senate candidate Mike Rogers had a shot at winning Michigan.
“I said, ‘Not with your tariffs,’” Whitmer told the crowd, adding that she hoped in vain that her candor would convince Trump to shift strategy. “I wasn’t trying to help Mike Rogers, by the way.”
What’s next?
Not a run for president, Whitmer said, noting a “big group of people” are likely to “duke it out” in 2028, but “it ain’t going to be me.”
“How many times do I have to answer this question?” the governor added.
Whitmer said she hasn’t decided what her next steps are after she leaves office, though she said she has “a lot of energy, and I want to make sure that I’m doing things that make me feel good, but also keep me challenged and excited.”
“I am going to try to be still for a little while and think about how I want to spend my next season,” she said.
Asked whether she had any words of wisdom for Benson, US Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed or other incoming Democratic officials, she said her only advice was “you’ve got to deliver.”
“It’s one thing to win the election, and another thing to do the work,” she said.
Benson is “ready” for the job and doesn’t need her advice, Whitmer said, but should she ask for it, “I will be a phone call away.”
