• Michigan lacks a statewide septic code, and up to 330,000 systems are failing
  • That has pushed billions of gallons of sewage into Michigan’s 76,000 miles of rivers and streams
  • While other states have cracked down, Michigan legislation is stalled and residents are frustrated

After years fixing septic systems in a state that does little to regulate them, it’s hard to gross out Rick Throop.

Bridge Listens: See how you can get involved

What you should know

Fecal-contaminated rivers expose Michiganders who swim, boat, or fish to bacteria, viruses and parasites from sewer overflows, farm runoff and failing septic systems. The contamination likely sickens thousands of people each year and can depress tourism and home values.

Who's making public decisions

The Michigan Legislature and EGLE hold the key authority over septic rules, farm manure regulation and enforcement, while local municipalities work to make sewer upgrades.

Ways to participate

What to watch for next

Watch whether state lawmakers take up a statewide septic code or stronger manure rules, and whether EGLE's ongoing E. coli testing leads to more waterways being listed as impaired.

Are you taking action? Let us know.

Powered by Civic Action Toolbox

But even he recoiled when he arrived at a jobsite to find no septic system at all — just a pipe leading from a waterfront cottage into the St. Clair River near Algonac.

“Do me a favor,” he instructed the owner. “Put a wad of toilet paper in your toilet and flush.”

Moments later, it was floating downstream.

The home was among up to 330,000 statewide with failing or nonexisting septic systems that shunt billions of gallons of sewage annually into Michigan’s rivers, lakes and aquifers. 

Related:

Along with sewer overflows in cities and manure runoff from farms, failing septics contribute to fecal pollution that makes some 75% of Michigan’s 76,000 miles of rivers and streams unsafe for swimming.

The pollution may sicken thousands of people a year. But efforts to fix it fizzle because of sticker shock: One recent estimate put the cost to replace Michigan’s failing septic systems at $2.2 billion or more, a bill that would fall to either taxpayers or individual homeowners at costs that can exceed $15,000 per job.

Scientists, public health experts and bipartisan lawmakers blame a regulatory system that too often turns a blind eye to problems. Michigan is the only state in the nation without a uniform septic code. In much of the state, officials don’t even know where all of them are located — much less which ones are failing.

Lawmakers have spent a quarter-century talking about the problem but taking little action.

Near-annual legislation to bolster oversight has failed amid concerns about logistics, costs and backlash from homeowners who could be forced to make repairs. 

“Nobody wants to be the bad guy,” said James Lower, a former Republican state representative who joined Democrat Abdullah Hammoud in a failed effort to adopt statewide regulations in 2018.

“The consequence, of course, is that there’s quite a bit of sewage going into our groundwater and surface water. It’s just a fact. And it’s unfortunate.”

While Michigan languishes, other states in recent years have cracked down. 

Beginning in February, all septic systems in Washington must be inspected and brought to code when properties are sold, following the lead of states like Ohio and Iowa that have required the inspections for more than a decade. States like Massachusetts go a step further, requiring upgraded systems in environmentally sensitive areas.

A deluge of poop 

Originally devised as a temporary solution for sparsely populated areas of a growing nation, septic systems have instead become permanent fixtures in many rural and suburban communities.

Michigan has about 1.3 million, outnumbering all but five states, according to state and US Census Bureau figures. 

The private disposal systems work by capturing sewage in an underground tank, where solids settle to the bottom and liquids seep into the ground. Under the right circumstances, soil filters bacteria, viruses and nutrients, leaving behind cleaner water. Tanks are meant to be periodically pumped to take care of the rest.

Several white perforated drainage pipes lie on the ground beside a pond bordered by trees with autumn foliage. Fallen leaves cover the muddy shoreline, and green algae float on portions of the water.
Old drain field pipe sits near the pond at Jennifer Kilgore’s home in Attica. When the clogged field stopped draining, the septic tank overflowed and sewage ran toward the water, said Rick Throop, whose crew is replacing the system. (Brayan Gutierrez for Bridge Michigan)

But when septic systems fail or are improperly located — say too close to the water table or a shoreline — wastewater leeches into aquifers, lakes and streams.

“We have decades of data now that says that’s going to cause water quality problems,” said Joan Rose, a Michigan State University microbiologist whose research has shown human feces is entering waterways near septic systems. 

Without a statewide code, systems are subject to a patchwork of local regulations that are often so weak they virtually guarantee pollution.

Some localities make it legal to build close to shorelines, drinking water wells or the underlying aquifer. 

While experts recommend drainfields be built 36 inches below the water table, for instance, the bar is lower in 33 Michigan counties, including heavily populated ones such as Macomb and Genesee.

Other localities allow systems packed side-by-side on tiny lots, where there isn’t enough soil to absorb all the toilet flushes and laundry loads. 

And though the average septic system fails after about 30 years, officials in 70 of Michigan’s 83 counties lack inspections to confirm older systems work.

Many homeowners don’t even know they own a septic, meaning they likely aren’t keeping up with maintenance.

“Failure isn’t always something you can see from the ground surface,” said Sara Heathman, an environmental quality specialist with the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy, which has long advocated for a statewide sanitary code that would require periodic inspections. 

In the handful of Michigan communities that require septic inspections before a home is sold, inspectors have found widespread problems: Pipes shunting human waste directly onto the ground, tanks punctured by tree roots and clogged drainfields located perilously close to a water source. 

A clear blue-green lake with several boats docked along wooden piers near a tree-lined shoreline. White clouds dot the bright blue sky above the water.
Fearing that septic pollution is harming Higgins Lake’s pristine waters, local public officials enacted a septic inspection ordinance that was later overturned. (Kelly House/Bridge Michigan)

Perhaps nowhere were the issues as severe as in Lyon Township, near Higgins Lake in Roscommon County, where a short-lived inspection program revealed health code violations at a majority of residences. 

The lake is renowned for its crystal blue waters carved by receding glaciers. But failing septic systems and fertilizer runoff are causing algae, odors and declining water quality. 

“Unfortunately, I think it’s something that’s often out of sight, out of mind,” said Taylor Irwin, environmental health director for the Central Michigan District Health Department, which covers six counties including Roscommon. 

Faced with the prospect of fixing failing septics or installing public sewers at a cost of $115 million, residents voted to recall most of the township board and elected newcomers who scrapped the inspection program. 

Similar voter resistance put an end to septic inspections in Barry and Eaton counties.

That kind of homeowner backlash also makes lawmakers wary of adopting a statewide septic code that would mandate periodic inspections. The latest proposal, spearheaded by state Sen. Sam Singh, D-East Lansing, has yet to get a floor vote with weeks left in the legislative session.

“I appreciate the concept of what we’re trying to achieve: Cleaner water, cleaner Michigan,” said state Sen. Michelle Hoitenga, R-Manton. “I just didn’t feel that there was any way for me to support something that the people I represent were in such opposition to.” 

The resulting pollution is compounded by a lack of resources to help the poorest Michiganders fix their failing septics. Routine tank pump-outs can cost up to $600, while full system replacement runs $10,000 or more — yet 12% of Americans can’t afford a sudden $400 expense.

“Money gets tight … the first thing people are going to look at is, do I put food in the fridge or pump my septic?” said Throop, the repairman. 

A yellow cordless drill and several loose screws rest on a round green septic tank access cover surrounded by dirt, grass and fallen autumn leaves.
A cleanout at Jennifer Kilgore’s home in Attica gives crews access to the septic system. (Brayan Gutierrez for Bridge Michigan)

Lawmakers took a step toward addressing the financial issue in 2024, when they authorized $35 million for a low-interest loan program to help low- and moderate-income Michiganders replace failing septics.

The program has helped roughly 475 homeowners. But nearly as many have been rejected because they’re too cash-strapped to qualify for a loan. 

“It happens quite frequently, and it’s heartbreaking,” said Nishaat Killeen, a programs director with Michigan Saves, the nonprofit that manages the loan program. 

Grant funding for the neediest homeowners would help fill the gap, Killeen said. But efforts to further boost septic repair funding have gained little traction in Lansing amid strained state budgets and growing anti-tax sentiment.

A dozen failed attempts

Since the turn of the millennium, lawmakers on both sides of the aisle have made more than a dozen attempts to enact a statewide code. Most never got a hearing in Lansing.

Lawmakers invariably say they care about cleaning up Michigan’s polluted water. But faced with the pushback from residents who own septic systems, they hesitate to regulate the pollution.

“Inaction wins the day,” said Singh. 

As in past years, Singh’s bill has stalled amid a debate about when — if ever — inspections should be required. 

Earlier bills called for point-of-sale inspections, but real estate agents objected, citing fears that the discovery of failing systems would slow sales. They advocated instead for periodic inspections at set time intervals.

A construction worker operates a CASE excavator, dumping gravel into a trench while another worker in a neon yellow shirt stands nearby holding a shovel and measuring rod. Piles of dirt and autumn-colored trees surround the excavation site.
Rick Throop operates an excavator as a coworker checks newly-installed drain field pipes at Jennifer Kilgore’s home in Attica. Tree roots had clogged the home’s old field, so the tank overflowed and sewage surfaced in the yard. (Brayan Gutierrez for Bridge Michigan)

Singh’s bill would require systems over 20 years old to be inspected once a decade, with a $50-per-inspection fee to help the state and local health departments administer the program.

But lobbying groups representing local governments and public health officials have complained they need more money to launch inspection programs and expressed fear of reprisals from angry homeowners. 

“It very well could be a safety issue for the inspectors,” said Kevin Green, environmental public health director for the Calhoun County Public Health Department.

A more manageable first step, Green said, would be to require inspections only for the highest-risk systems, such as those next to lakes or rivers. Lawmakers could gradually expand oversight, while mapping the state’s septic systems to help local officials enforce existing rules.

But environmental advocates argue a code so limited in scope would allow hundreds of thousands of failing systems to keep polluting Michigan’s water.

And it would be of little help to people like Jennifer and Ken Kilgore. 

The pair had barely moved into the 47-year-old home in rural Lapeer County this year when they noticed sewage oozing onto the lawn.

As they prepare to shell out $14,000 for a full septic system replacement, they’re left to wonder whether a point-of-sale inspection could have helped them avoid the sudden expense.

“I’m just shocked it’s not a thing,” Jennifer Kilgore said, “because everybody’s on a septic field out here.”

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under our Republication Guidelines. Questions? Email republishing@bridgemi.com