MSU trustee sues, says ethics policy is unconstitutional

Michigan State University Trustee Mike Balow says he and Trustee Rema Vassar have been disenfranchised from the MSU board after failing to sign an ethics policy they regard as silencing them
Balow filed a federal lawsuit against MSU’s board chair and secretary, the second lawsuit against university officials this month. Vassar also sued the MSU president and others, alleging racial discrimination
Board Chair Briana Scott said, ‘The code does not limit speech’

Michigan State University Trustee Mike Balow says he has worked behind the scenes for months to get the university’s board to modify its controversial ethics policy, updated last spring to include what some viewed as a loyalty clause amid some trustees publicly questioning university policies.

Balow decided he’s had enough. This week, he filed a federal lawsuit against board Chair Briana Scott and board Secretary Stefan Fletcher, alleging the updated policy is unconstitutional.

The updated policy is viewed by some as silencing elected officials but supporters say it reinforces boardmember responsibilities. It includes provisions such as one requiring trustees to support and not undermine decisions made by the majority of the board and another requiring trustees to act after board decisions “consistent with our fiduciary duties, including the duty of loyalty.”

“History teaches that self-government breaks down when those in power use governmental authority to silence dissent,” saysthe lawsuit, filed on Balow’s behalf by the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, a national organization fighting for rights of those on and off college campuses.

A man poses for a photo — Michigan State University Trustee Mike Balow has filed a lawsuit against the board chair and secretary, alleging an updated board ethics policy is unconstitutional. (Marcie Kay Photography)

“Under the board’s new rules, trustees may praise MSU’s leadership all they want, but they face sanctions if they publicly criticize it,” the lawsuit continues. “That is blatant viewpoint discrimination, repugnant to our Constitution and political tradition.”

RELATED:

Scott, the board chair, said MSU’s updated ethics policy contains similar provisions to one enacted for Wayne State University’s board and state lawmakers are expected to follow the rules of their respective House and Senate chambers, as enforced by the speaker and majority leader.

“The purpose of the Code of Ethics and Conduct is to help ensure the Board can effectively govern in service to students, faculty, staff, parents, research partners, taxpayers and the broader public,” Scott said in a statement. “The code does not limit speech or restrict members of governing boards from raising concerns, providing oversight or questioning decisions; instead, it establishes good and commonsense governance practices.” 

Balow’s lawsuit is the second filed this month against MSU officials by a board member. Trustee Rema Vassar last week filed a federal lawsuit against MSU President Kevin Guskiewicz and others, alleging racial discrimination.

“The university will respond to the accusations in Trustee Vassar’s lawsuit through the applicable legal process,” MSU spokesperson Amber McCann said

Balow said that he andVassar have been shut out of about 20 MSU events where other trustees were invited since they decided not to sign the policy in May. And the events from which they have been excluded go beyond football games, Balow added, from the Mackinac Policy Conference to the president’s State of the University address to a dinner to thank employers who worked to restore power to campus after a major outage.

Even when he tried to address it on a board phone call, he said the response from other trustees was “crickets” and then they moved on.

“We are going to take a deep dive into the constitutionality of the code and we are going to show it is not the right policy for MSU or any university that silences board members,” said Balow. “We are going to make Michigan State a better place.”

Thank you to our Education Watch sponsors

Bridge Michigan Education Watch is made possible by generous financial support from our sponsors. Sponsorship supports our independent journalism mission but does not constitute sponsor endorsement of individual articles or editorial content. Bridge Michigan journalism remains fact- and data-driven and independent at all times.

Please visit the About page for more information and to subscribe to Education Watch. Interested in becoming a sponsor? Contact Emma Carr.