- Despite progress, systems that serve one-third of Michigan still dump sewage into the state’s rivers
- Upgrades cost billions of dollars and often are delayed because of other priorities
- Other states have made progress, but deadlines repeatedly come and go in Michigan cities to fix the problem
When Nicky Marcot bought land on the Rouge River for an urban farm in 2006, she imagined tending backyard crops while her children explored the wooded riverbank.
Those dreams washed away the first time it rained and a flood of toilet water swamped her lawn.
Even a brief shower can overwhelm Detroit’s sewers, sending a polluted mix of stormwater and sewage into the Rouge just upstream of Marcot’s house in Detroit’s Brightmoor neighborhood. The rains leave a stench that can linger long after the waters recede.
“Who wants to eat a head of lettuce that got covered in sewer overflow?” Marcot asked, much less let their kids play in the river.

Despite a decades-old legal obligation to stop using rivers as emergency waste conduits, Detroit and several other Michigan cities are slow to comply, missing deadlines as other priorities take precedence in the battle for scarce public funds.
Bridge Listens: See how you can get involved
What you should know
Fecal-contaminated rivers expose Michiganders who swim, boat, or fish to bacteria, viruses and parasites from sewer overflows, farm runoff and failing septic systems. The contamination likely sickens thousands of people each year and can depress tourism and home values.
Who's making public decisions
The Michigan Legislature and EGLE hold the key authority over septic rules, farm manure regulation and enforcement, while local municipalities work to make sewer upgrades.
Ways to participate
- Look up your state lawmakers on the state House Natural Resources and Tourism Committee →
Contact state representatives who work on the environment. - Look up your state lawmakers on the state Senate Energy and Environment Committee →
Contact state senators dealing with environmental issues. - Attend the Grand Traverse County Board of Public Works meeting →
The board meets the second Thursday of the month at Garfield Township Hall, and its verified agenda includes well and water tank inspections, sewer pump station upgrades for several townships, and a state violation notice over a sewage overflow. - See the DWSD’s upcoming meetings →
The story names the DWSD. We do not list its meetings yet, so check its own schedule for the next one. - Look up EGLE water quality reports →
What to watch for next
Are you taking action? Let us know.
Powered by Civic Action Toolbox
While most sewer overflow issues have been fixed, nearly a third of Michigan’s population — some 3 million people — are served by antiquated systems that still periodically overflow.
In recent years, that’s dumped as much as 9 billions of gallons of untreated sewage into Michigan rivers.
It’s part of a toxic stew that has made 75% of Michigan’s 300-plus rivers and streams unsafe for swimming, likely sickening thousands of residents. Other culprits include livestock farms and septic systems.
Related:
- Pure Michigan has a poop problem: Dangerous fecal levels befoul 3 of 4 rivers
- Michigan has ignored faulty septic systems for decades. The bill is coming due
Stopping Michigan’s spills may take billions of dollars. While Grand Rapids and other communities have borrowed money to get the job done on time, leaders of other water systems say residents struggle to afford new debt or higher water rates.
“If we had all the money in the world, would we address all the outfalls? Of course,” said Navid Mehram, wastewater chief for the Great Lakes Water Authority, which manages regional sewers for dozens of southeast Michigan communities.
With the state and federal governments offering limited help, Marcot and other residents are left to endure pollution with no clear end in sight.
“It’s just such a flabbergasting issue to have in the 21st century,” she said. “You read about the sewage in London back in 1800 that was causing cholera. We’re not supposed to have to deal with issues like this anymore.”

While states throughout the northeast have struggled with similar problems, some of Michigan’s neighbors have made recent strides in addressing them.
Indiana has reduced its sewage overflows by 71% since 2004 by diverting money for repairs and mandating system audits. In Ohio, a 2011 federal consent decree led to $2.4 billion in upgrades that have prevented 2 billion gallons of overflows a year from reaching Lake Erie.
Fixing Michigan’s overflow problem is “totally doable,” said Donna Kashian, director of environmental science at Wayne State University.
“It’s just the commitment.”
Delay after delay

Modern sewer systems are built with two pipes: One that carries wastewater to treatment plants and another that whisks rainwater to the nearest river.
But cities developed before the mid-1900s often have so-called combined sewers, which drain gutters and toilets into a single pipe that overflows into rivers when it rains.
By the late 20th century, the resulting pollution shocked the state and federal governments into action. Cities were put on deadlines to stop the overflows.
Among those that still have not finished the job:
- Lansing, which was supposed to separate its sewer and stormwater systems by 2020. It could take another 25 years.
- Detroit, where a 2022 deadline to eliminate high-priority outfalls has been repeatedly extended. With 55 outfalls remaining, officials are not sure the new 2037 deadline is feasible.
- Manistique, which is working to eliminate its final untreated outfall.
- Dearborn, which has five untreated outfalls on the Rouge River.
- Niles, which still has one on the St. Joseph River.
- St. Joseph, which aims to eliminate discharges from its three remaining outfalls by 2030.
- The Detroit suburbs, where a combined 13 outfalls await action.
Michigan officials say they’re working as fast as funding allows.
Federal grants have shrunk considerably since the 1970s, when they covered more than half of water infrastructure spending. Today, it’s about 7%, according to figures from the US Water Alliance.
State funding for water projects is also limited, dwarfed by other priorities. For example, Michigan devotes just $200 million in non-federal funding to water infrastructure, compared to more than $5 billion for roads.
“People see the roads every day and they know when roads are underfunded,” said Andy Kilpatrick, Lansing’s public services director. “But they don’t think about what’s under the ground.”
Strategies to address overflows include installing modern separated sewers, building massive overflow retention basins or using “green infrastructure” to absorb rainfall before it can flow into gutters.
Even with the missed deadlines, Michigan has made progress, said Charles Hill, a wastewater specialist at the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy.
Since 1988, the number of uncontrolled outfalls statewide has plunged from 613 to 99, he said.
“You’re usually knocking away the low-hanging fruit first,” he said, which means remaining overflows will be costly and complicated to fix.
Statewide, Michigan communities are bracing for $15 billion in unfunded stormwater and wastewater infrastructure needs in the coming two decades, according to a 2022 congressional report.
The state’s broader water infrastructure system needs $85 billion in investment over the same time period, according to a September report commissioned by the Great Lakes Water Authority, southeast Michigan’s regional water provider.
A struggle to make fixes
In Detroit, officials have spent more than $1.4 billion on overflow reduction efforts that first began in the 1990s, but cash shortages make it tough to finish the job. Efforts to raise new revenue – such as the fee dubbed the “rain tax” by some city residents – have not been popular.
The city’s latest plan emphasizes green infrastructure such as rain gardens and engineered wetlands, which alleviate pressure on sewers by diverting water elsewhere.
It’s often far cheaper than separating sewers or building treatment basins. But even so, it’s not clear the city will meet its 2037 deadline to eliminate high-priority outfalls.
“The reality of it is, we haven’t identified the funding,” said Sam Smalley, deputy director of the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department.
Many Detroit residents struggle to pay bills that fund water system upgrades, and overflow mitigation competes with a laundry list of other priorities, from replacing ancient water mains to eliminating lead drinking water lines.
More efficient plumbing, suburban flight and industry loss have all exacerbated the crisis, leaving cities with fewer customers to pay the bills.
Lansing, which has lost 17,500 residents and auto factories since its 1970s peak, was forced to pause sewer separations for several years as costs nearly bankrupted the city sewer fund.
The city of 113,000 residents now spends $30 million annually on the project with help from a low-interest state loan. It faces a 2035 deadline to stop overflows, but officials acknowledge work may not be done until 2050.
“There’s a political reality that if we raise our rates too much, there will be backlash,” said Kilpatrick, the city’s public services director.
Michigan cities are not alone. Similar issues plague hundreds of communities nationwide, particularly older cities in the northeast and Great Lakes.
Cities that have managed to eliminate combined sewer overflows have often issued large revenue bonds to finance the work, with ratepayers paying off the debt over decades.

Grand Rapids, for example, spent $400 million on a sewer separation project that wrapped up in 2015. Pressure from downstream communities, political will among local leaders and favorable borrowing terms prompted the investment, said city Utilities Director Wayne Jernberg.
Sewer rates have gone up as a result. But a Grand Valley State University study commissioned by the city showed city residents have realized billions in returns from higher property values, cleaner beaches, reduced water treatment costs and other benefits.
“It also opened up access to the river,” Jernberg said.
He cited Canal Park, which is north of downtown.
“When there were sewage issues in the past, not many people wanted to be down and around there,” Jernberg said. “Now this fall, the number of people down there fishing on the river was a ton. Part of that is, they know the river is a lot cleaner.”
The ‘plastic wrap’ problem
While municipalities struggle to come up with funding, climate change and continued sprawl are making the problem worse.
Warmer air increases evaporation from the Earth’s surface while allowing the atmosphere to hold more of that moisture. The end result is intense storms that dump far more water at a time.

Total annual precipitation in Michigan has increased by 14% since 1951, mostly due to an increase in the severity of heavy storms. Think the damaging southeast Michigan floods of 2021 and the rain and snowmelt-driven floods of this past April.
The trend will continue unless humanity dramatically cuts back on fossil fuel-driven greenhouse gas emissions that are warming Earth’s atmosphere.
Meanwhile, sprawling suburban development is continuing apace even while Michigan’s population remains stagnant and is predicted to sharply decline in the coming decades.
That spreads tax dollars ever-thinner across an expanding network of pipes, roads and power lines. And it further strains sewers by replacing spongy soil with rooftops and blacktop that can’t absorb rain.
“It’s like taking plastic wrap and spreading it over the landscape,” said Cameron Davis, a vice president at GEI Consultants who authored a report on metro Detroit’s sewer overflows.
Money for fixes?
One way to speed up fixes is for the state to offer more financial help.
A proposal in Lansing, spearheaded by state Sen. Sam Singh, would impose a 25-cent-per-gallon royalty on bottled water companies to generate $300 million annually for Michigan’s water systems.
Modeled after a similar fund that uses oil and gas drilling royalties to purchase and improve public land, Singh sees the proposal as a politically palatable way to capture revenue from an industry that now pays almost nothing to export Michigan’s water.
“We wanted to look at a model that’s worked really well for us,” Singh, D-East Lansing, said, without raising taxes on residents.
Its prospects are dim: The bills have not received a hearing, with just weeks left in the legislative session.
A Great Lakes Water Authority report explored a range of other ideas, from a half-cent increase in the state sales tax (which would require voter approval) and a new state revenue bond to repealing preferential policies that give some groups a tax discount while costing Michigan $32 billion annually.
“None of these options are politically easy,” the authors wrote, but “without leadership and vision, the state’s water crisis will only continue compounding for future generations.”
Short of more money to speed the pace of sewer overflow fixes, Davis said Michigan policymakers and residents would be wise to stop aggravating the problem with runaway sprawl.
“We need to start thinking about our landscape as a form of infrastructure,” he said.
“If you’re building an addition to your house, that’s more hardscape and that water has to go somewhere.”
Detroit has begun doing so, with a stormwater ordinance that requires new developments with more than a half-acre of impervious surfaces to build onsite rain gardens or other stormwater solutions.
Because the city is “the low point of the bathtub” in a stormwater network that extends well into the suburbs, Smalley said Detroit has also gotten aggressive about pressing neighboring cities to reduce their runoff.
“I’m not entirely confident that we’ll make the 2037 (deadline),” he said, “but we are making continual good progress.”




You must be logged in to post a comment.