• Michigan rivers are suffering as the industrial-scale livestock industry expands in nearby communities
  • The Pine River in Gratiot County is among the casualties, with fecal pollution levels that have skyrocketed in recent years
  • State officials want to tighten manure pollution controls, but are caught in a yearslong legal battle with industry

GRATIOT COUNTY — For generations in this agricultural region in the heart of Michigan’s Lower Peninsula, summertime revolved around fishing, boating and swimming in the tranquil Pine River.

Not anymore.

Bridge Listens: See how you can get involved

What you should know

Fecal-contaminated rivers expose Michiganders who swim, boat, or fish to bacteria, viruses and parasites from sewer overflows, farm runoff and failing septic systems. The contamination likely sickens thousands of people each year and can depress tourism and home values.

Who's making public decisions

The Michigan Legislature and EGLE hold the key authority over septic rules, farm manure regulation and enforcement, while local municipalities work to make sewer upgrades.

Ways to participate

What to watch for next

Watch whether state lawmakers take up a statewide septic code or stronger manure rules, and whether EGLE's ongoing E. coli testing leads to more waterways being listed as impaired.

Are you taking action? Let us know.

Powered by Civic Action Toolbox

One by one, residents have pulled docks, sold boats and stowed tackleboxes as much of the river has transformed into a feces-tainted mess, unsafe for swimming and often too weedy to navigate by boat. 

The situation is bleaker in some feeder creeks, where putrid brown water hardly harbors a frog or fish.

“It’s enough to wake you up at night from the smell,” said 78-year-old Jane Jelenek, whose family has owned the same waterfront home for six decades.

The Pine is among some three-quarters of Michigan’s rivers and streams polluted by levels of human and animal waste that exceed state water quality standards and may sicken thousands of residents per year.

Related:

Environmental groups blame pollution in the Pine on waste from ballooning livestock herds at concentrated animal feeding operations, or CAFOs. They have proliferated in Gratiot County and across Michigan since the turn of the millennium, replacing mom-and-pop farms with vast feedlots that raise livestock by the thousands. 

“Something has got to give, because what is clear is that the land cannot absorb the amount of waste that is being applied and sliding off into rivers, lakes and groundwater,” said Liz Kirkwood, strategic partnership officer for Flow Water Advocates, which is involved in a legal fight over Michigan’s efforts to regulate the operations.

The industrial facilities achieve economies of scale to deliver low-cost meat, eggs and dairy to US consumers, who eat far more of it than the global average. And for farmers, who don’t control the price their product commands, growth is survival.

“Smaller farms have less financial cushion to survive down cycles,” said David Ortega, an agricultural economist at Michigan State University. “The result is production increasingly concentrated in fewer, larger operations.”

The byproduct of this consolidation: Staggering quantities of feces and urine — 420 million gallons annually in Gratiot County alone — which CAFOs dispose of by spreading it untreated onto nearby fields. 

Collectively, Michigan’s 272 largest CAFOs generate more waste than the state’s entire human population — 1.1 million solid tons and 3.93 billion liquid gallons in 2024, according to state records analyzed by Bridge.

That’s enough to fill 1,000 tanker trucks a day.

State officials acknowledge too much ends up in rivers across the state, fueling bacteria outbreaks, weed and algae overgrowth and oxygen-depleted water where fish can’t breathe. 

“That harm compounds with each passing month,” Assistant Attorney General Elizabeth Morrisseau wrote in a June legal filing on the topic.

But regulators have struggled to curb the pollution amid a yearslong court battle with the farm industry. It contends stricter waste control could drive farms out of business.

“Efforts to increase farmers’ red tape, paperwork, operational limitations, governmental reports and so forth will have no positive effect,” Michigan Farm Bureau lawyer Any Kok said in a statement last November. 

A man wearing a pink shirt, white pants and purple gloves stands atop a corrugated metal culvert, looking down at a stream surrounded by tall grass and wildflowers.
Alma College professor Murray Borrello has spent decades monitoring E. coli and other pollutants in the Pine River and its tributaries. The watershed’s health has declined in lockstep with the expansion of large livestock operations. (Kelly House/Bridge Michigan)

Amid the debate, some along this river have begun to fear that by the time regulations catch up to the pollution, the Pine will be too far gone to recover.

“Every year is worse than the one before,” said Jelenek, who no longer touches the water for fear of getting sick. 

“The rules are written for the CAFOs. They’re not written for the rest of us that live here.”

‘The watershed is dying’

Gratiot County is a hub of a statewide CAFO industry that has expanded threefold in the past quarter-century.

There are now 272 regulated CAFOs in Michigan, each with a minimum of 1,000 cattle, 700 dairy cows, 80,000 laying hens or 2,500 pigs. More operations avoid regulation by staying just under those size thresholds.

Unlike traditional farms where livestock graze in open pastures, CAFOs raise cattle, swine and poultry by the thousands in confined spaces, collecting their waste in sheds or lagoons before trucking it to nearby fields.

They tend to crop up in clusters, concentrating vast quantities of waste in just a handful of communities. 

“Too much in one spot is part of the issue,” said Bruce Washburn, an environmental quality specialist within the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy Water Resources Division.

Gratiot County has 24 CAFOs — more per square mile than anywhere in the state. Since the turn of the millennium, its cattle herd has more than doubled while hog counts have tripled.

Other hubs include dairy operations in the Thumb, along the Ohio border and in the central-northern Lower Peninsula; hog farms in Mason and Oceana counties near the central Lake Michigan coast; and poultry and swine operations that fan out south of Grand Rapids.

When applied judiciously, nitrogen and phosphorus in manure is a useful fertilizer. But research shows that today’s farms often apply more than crops can absorb. And CAFO waste often isn’t manure alone, but a slurry-like mix of feces, urine and wastewater.

A flooded agricultural field with standing water, muddy patches and crop residue stretches toward distant farm buildings under a clear blue sky.
Waste and meltwater pool at the edge of a farm field after being applied to snow-covered ground that later thawed — an example of the pollution that can occur when CAFO waste is applied in wintertime. (Courtesy of EGLE)

The resulting pollution has become a nationwide public health crisis, harming ecosystems and tainting drinking water near farms from Iowa to the Carolinas. 

Michigan is not alone in its struggle to address it.

“Nobody adequately regulates these things,” said Bob Martin, a farm policy advocate who led the American Public Health Association’s call for a moratorium on CAFO expansions until stricter rules are in place.  

The state deems a waterway out of compliance for swimming if the number of E. coli — one of many potentially harmful germs found in feces — exceeds 300 per 100-millileters of water (just under a half-cup) in a single sample, or a mean of 130 E. coli across multiple samples during a 30-day period. 

The limit for paddling, wading and fishing is 1,000 E. coli. 

These days, almost nowhere in the Pine River basin consistently makes the grade.

“The watershed is dying,” said Murray Borrello, an Alma College professor who has spent two decades monitoring its decline.

When it rains, E. coli levels in creeks near CAFO waste application fields can spike to 10 times the limit for safe human contact, according to Borrello’s research.

Much of the bacteria is antibiotic-resistant, which he attributed to regular antibiotic use to promote growth and suppress disease in cramped livestock pens.

Levels of phosphorus — a nutrient found in feces — have also skyrocketed in the Pine, fueling thick weeds and algae in the once-clear water.

Data from across the state shows similar trends in Michigan’s other livestock industry hotspots. The data shows these hotspots exceed state limits for fecal and/or nutrient pollution.

Industry officials dispute CAFOs’ role in Michigan’s pollution and often point to other potential culprits, such as leaky septic systems. But data from the Pine River watershed casts doubt on those arguments.

Water sampling data collected by Borrello and his students shows areas immediately upstream and downstream of the facilities can have dramatically different pollution levels. And when a CAFO closes, nearby water quality quickly improves.

“The CAFO impact is so immense, it dwarfs any impact from other inputs,” Borrello said.

A man handles fishing gear while two children hold fishing rods on a wooden dock overlooking a lake.
Ray Hitsman baits a line for his grandkids, Brynlei Conner and Nolan Measel, as the group fish at the Pine River in Alma. Nearby, a sign warns visitors that the water has high levels of E. coli, one of many potentially harmful pathogens caused by feces in the water. (Kelly House/Bridge Michigan)

CAFO owners say they’re doing their best to prevent pollution, but curtailing manure spreading would eat into thin margins. Renting a tanker to haul waste costs upwards of $300 an hour. If manure must be spread thinner, then CAFOs will face higher hauling costs and stiffer competition for available land.

“You can chew up a lot of money in a hurry, going an extra mile or an extra two miles,” said John Crain, a feedlot owner in the village of Breckenridge.

Bridge Michigan reached out repeatedly to industry representatives, including the Michigan Farm Bureau, local Farm Bureau offices, the Michigan Milk Producers Association, Michigan Pork Producers Association and lawyers representing the CAFO industry. None would comment for this story. 

In legal filings and past public comments, industry advocates have described CAFO owners as environmental stewards. Land-applying waste, they argue, is beneficial because it helps farmers avoid the use of synthetic fertilizers.

“Our farmers have more interest than anyone in preserving the state’s ecosystem for the future,” the Farm Bureau’s Kok said during a public hearing last year.

It’s not convincing to Dennis Kellogg, a sixth-generation farmer who has seen and smelled the difference between CAFOs and the dairy farm he grew up on.

“Never in my life did my dad or I haul loaded manure spreaders through the streets of Ithaca, Michigan,” Kellogg said.

A large silver tanker truck turns onto a wet rural road on an overcast, rainy day, with farmland and buildings in the background.
A manure tanker travels down the road in rural Gratiot County. The tankers have become a common sight on local roads as a surging livestock population leads to more manure that is spread on local farms. (Kelly House/Bridge Michigan)

On a recent afternoon just outside Ithaca, semi-sized CAFO waste tankers rumbled down the highway at a rate of about one every two-and-a-half minutes while rain dampened the surrounding fields.

Eleven years and counting

State regulators acknowledge their CAFO waste policies aren’t keeping Michigan’s water clean. But their efforts to tighten them have so far stalled amid a yearslong legal battle with the industry.

Since 2005, Michigan’s largest CAFOs have been required to obtain waste disposal permits with terms meant to limit pollution.

Among other things, they must check for signs of runoff after spreading waste on drainpiped fields, avoid spreading on flooded fields and stop using fields once phosphorus levels climb to three times the amount considered useful for crops.

By 2020, when Michigan’s general permit was due for a scheduled five-year update, regulators saw a need for tighter controls.

After months of negotiations with industry and environmentalists, they unveiled a new permit that prohibited waste applications within 100 feet of water bodies and required receiving fields to have grassy buffers along ditches, creek banks and drainage pipe intakes. 

It further limited applications on high-phosphorus fields. And it banned most spreading from January through most of March, when the ground is often frozen and there are no crops to absorb the fertilizer.

“The longer waste is on a field before it can be utilized, the higher the risk,” EGLE’s Washburn said of the winter ban.

The Michigan Farm Bureau and a collection of CAFOs and industry groups sued and mounted an administrative challenge, triggering a yearslong legal battle that remains in play today.

Their lawsuit argued regulators lacked authority to update the permit and failed to prove the changes would help the environment. It claimed the new regulations would turn farmland into “economically useless wilderness.”

The battle spilled over into the Legislature, where state Republicans have spent considerable time this session blasting state environmental officials for what they see as heavy-handed regulations on industry. They say the state should focus on policing bad actors rather than tightening regulations across the board.

“I would have more respect for EGLE if they just told me they don’t want CAFO farms, instead of trying to regulate them out of business,” said Sen. Roger Hauck, whose mid-Michigan district includes Gratiot County.

Democrats in the Legislature are more welcoming of the state’s attempts to tighten pollution limits, contending Michigan must prioritize public health above private business interests when the two are in conflict.

“The industrial farms need to be regulated,” said state Rep. Mike McFall, a Troy Democrat and minority vice chair of the House Natural Resources Committee. “This isn’t mom and pops anymore.”

The war of words in courtrooms and hearing halls doesn’t neatly match the narrative on the ground. 

Crain, the Breckenridge feedlot owner, said he would be willing to endure more regulation if he knew it would help the Pine: “I don’t want to live in a polluted environment either.” 

But he fears too much could prompt a new wave of consolidation, or an exodus to lower-regulation states that would harm Michigan’s rural economies. 

Others have suggested a limit on the number of cows allowed per township or county — a move that could tamp down on pollution while supporting local farmers who face stiff competition for land as newcomers enter the region.

The permit dispute appeared near-settled in 2024, when the Michigan Supreme Court upheld EGLE’s right to regulate. 

But soon after EGLE Director Phil Roos issued a final permit that further tamped down on waste spreading, the farm coalition sued again. 

Both sides are now appealing a June 2026 ruling that axed several of EGLE’s permit terms and kept others intact.

The continued impasse has prompted furor from environmentalists, who say Michigan is running out of time to avert ecological disaster in places like Gratiot County.

“EGLE has basically been handcuffed for the past six years from taking the very necessary steps that are needed,” said Katie Garvey, a lawyer with the Environmental Law & Policy Center, which has joined the state in its appeal.

A large herd of black-and-white dairy cows stands and rests inside an open-sided barn with metal railings and exposed wooden beams.
Cattle inside a shed at High Line Cattle Feeding, one of 25 confined animal feeding operations in Gratiot County. (Kelly House/Bridge Michigan)

Meanwhile, Gratiot County’s dairy herd keeps growing. In July, state regulators approved a new 3,450-head CAFO that will add up to 34 million liquid gallons of manure to the local landscape.

As the Pine River’s health deteriorates, so does Jelenek’s hope for a turnaround.

“Somebody’s going to have to get sick and probably die from the E. coli before anything’s really done about it,” she said.

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under our Republication Guidelines. Questions? Email republishing@bridgemi.com