• Michigan’s rivers are polluted by feces, but experts say the problem can be alleviated
  • Proposed fixes include inspecting and fixing septic systems, reforming Michigan’s farm pollution regulations and funding sewer repairs
  • Lawmakers are split on the best approach and in some cases, whether action is even necessary

Fecal pollution has made a mess out of Michigan’s rivers and streams, but experts say tougher regulations, cultural changes and investment can begin to fix the problem.

Look no further than history. 

Bridge Listens: See how you can get involved

What you should know

Fecal-contaminated rivers expose Michiganders who swim, boat, or fish to bacteria, viruses and parasites from sewer overflows, farm runoff and failing septic systems. The contamination likely sickens thousands of people each year and can depress tourism and home values.

Who's making public decisions

The Michigan Legislature and EGLE hold the key authority over septic rules, farm manure regulation and enforcement, while local municipalities work to make sewer upgrades.

Ways to participate

What to watch for next

Watch whether state lawmakers take up a statewide septic code or stronger manure rules, and whether EGLE's ongoing E. coli testing leads to more waterways being listed as impaired.

Are you taking action? Let us know.

Powered by Civic Action Toolbox

In the 1960s, the Rouge River was so polluted it caught fire and one stretch of the Clinton River could not support any fish. A decade earlier, the odor of industrial waste in the Kalamazoo River spurred officials to action.

In more recent years, Michigan has curbed pollution from phosphate-based detergents and industrial PFAS discharges — and rivers and wildlife have bounced back.

“Rivers are resilient…they just need a little bit of help,” said Robert Burns, who has served for more than 20 years as the Detroit riverkeeper. 

“If you do your due diligence, you make that little effort to help clean things up and to reduce the influx (if pollution), the river will help clean itself up over time.”

Related:

Now, with some 75% of Michigan rivers and streams containing fecal pollution that exceed limits meant to protect swimmers and anglers, experts say the time has come again for a concentrated push to protect the state’s waters.

Bridge Michigan spoke to more than four dozen residents, experts, advocates and legislators about what needs to be done. 

Here are four actions legislators can take — and one for everyday people to do their part.

Regulate septic systems

Michigan is the only state in the nation without a uniform statewide sanitary code. It instead relies on a patchwork of inconsistent and often loosely-enforced local regulations.

It’s a system that allows an estimated 330,000 failing septic systems to pollute with little oversight. 

Water advocates have long pushed for a statewide code that requires septic systems to be periodically inspected to ensure they’re working properly. 

The concept has garnered bipartisan support, but so far, bills to adopt a statewide code have floundered amid concerns about the cost of fixes and disagreement about when inspections should happen.

“This is the type of legislation the next governor should run with and just say, “I did it,’” said Liz Kirkwood, strategic partnership officer at Flow Water Advocates. “Here you go. We’re the 50th state.”

Bolster state oversight

The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy has more than 1,600 employees. 

Only one is charged with full-time monitoring of the state’s rivers and streams for E. coli, the gut bacteria that is an indicator of fecal pollution levels. 

Meanwhile, staffing to enforce manure pollution regulations at large livestock farms has remained largely unchanged in recent decades while the number of farms has tripled. Currently, seven people are devoted at least part-time to ensuring compliance.

Environmental advocates argue such limited staffing limits the state’s ability to investigate pollution and keep tabs on industry to ensure rules are followed.

However, contending EGLE’s regulatory approach is too heavy-handed, Republican lawmakers have recently pushed to reduce its staffing and cut its budget.

Rethink farm pollution

Agricultural runoff is the nation’s leading source of river pollution, according to the US Environmental Protection Agency. 

Michigan is no exception.

Yet for the most part, the state and federal government don’t regulate it as closely as factories or water treatment plants, instead relying on voluntary efforts to curb the diffuse pollution that flows off farm fields.

The largest livestock farms are a notable exception – the state requires them to obtain permits with terms meant to prevent pollution, but few believe the system is working well.

Environmentalists and state regulators say permit terms are too weak. Farm groups have fought efforts to strengthen them, contending the changes are confusing, contradictory and onerous.

All the while, Michigan’s manure pollution problem grows worse while some lawmakers do little to intervene.

Eric Dennis, a research associate at the Citizens Research Council who has studied the issue, said Michigan should rethink its regulatory approach, rather than tweaking a permit system that only applies to a subset of farmers and is widely viewed as ineffective.

“We need to find a better way to do this,” he said. 

Fund sewer fixes

Cities across the state are under decades-old orders to update the antiquated “combined sewers” that overflow when it rains, but funding woes have kept them from finishing the job. 

Experts say part of the problem is that the federal government stopped chipping in much money to pay for water infrastructure upgrades, and the state never filled the gap.

That left Michigan’s aging core cities to absorb more of the bill just as suburban flight, deindustrialization and improved water efficiency were cutting into their water system revenue.

The state now devotes $200 million in non-federal dollars to water infrastructure per year — a fraction of the $5 billion spent on roads. 

Lawmakers for years have pondered proposals to boost funding, including a current bill that would impose a 25 cent-per-gallon royalty on bottled water companies to fund water initiatives.

Scoop the poop

Some of the hardest-to-tackle pollution comes from pet and waterfowl poop that escapes into waterways due to human actions.

Michigan has 2.4 million dogs, and experts say not enough owners pick up their waste.

Meanwhile, development that replaced wetland and forests with grassy waterfront lawns has created ideal habitat for geese and ducks to congregate, while making it easy for droppings to run off into the water.

“I don’t know if people understand their personal relationship with the water or how connected they are to it,” said Rachel Cuschieri-Murray, executive director of the Eaton Conservation District. “Education is a big piece of the puzzle.”

You can help by promptly picking up after your pet. If you live near the water, consider swapping the turfgrass for tall native grasses and shrubs. 

If your home has an illicit sewer connection or a malfunctioning septic system, getting it fixed will also shrink your fecal footprint.

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under our Republication Guidelines. Questions? Email republishing@bridgemi.com